RESEARCH ISSUES

Next page
 
EUTHANASIA

Definition:

A gentle death that is regarded as a act of humane killing with the minimum of pain, fear and distress.


Objectives:

  • Painless 
  • Unconsciousness and death are achieved rapidly 
  • Minimal restraint and psychological stress 
  • Simple, reliable, reproducible and irreversible
  • Safe for the operator


Clinical Endpoints:

"In experiments involving animals, any actual or potential pain, distress or discomfort should be minimized or alleviated by choosing the earliest endpoint that is compatible with scientific objectives of the research. " 
- CCAC, 1998 
The clinical endpoint lists the conditions, complications and criteria that would lead to euthanasia of an animal before the  expected completion of the experiment, e.g. more than 20% weight loss, maximum tumour size, vocalizing, lack of grooming.
 

Experimental Endpoints:
The experimental endpoint, is the estimated survival time for the animals. 
 

Reasons for Euthanasia:

     
    Humane endpoint:
    • Levels of pain, distress and suffering exceed acceptable limits
    • Specific guidelines for physiological parameters (weight loss, reduced mobility, alterations in core body temperature etc) 
    • Specific guidelines for certain areas of research (neoplasia, toxicology)


    Experimental endpoint: 

    • Experimental objectives / results are achieved
    • Tissue harvesting
    • No longer suitable for breeding
    • Unwanted genotype / phenotype 
    • Questionable / undesirable health status 


Recognition and Confirmation of Death:

  • Cessation of heartbeat and respiration
  • Absence of all reflexes
  • Central, fixed dilated pupil  (easier to detect in larger species)
  • Chemical and physical methods


Acceptable Methods of Euthanasia:

  • Species dependent
  • Methods differ for anaesthetized vs. unanaesthetized animals
  • Physical methods must cause immediate loss of consciousness through physical trauma to the brain


Recommended Methods of Euthanasia:
What best describes a good method of euthanasia is that it consistently produces a humane death.

  • For chemical euthanasia, the intravenous route is always preferable to intraperitoneal route due to rapid induction and a quick, humane death. 
  • For physical euthanasia, prior anaesthesia is mandatory. If there is no anaesthesia administered prior to a physical means of euthanasia, scientific justification must be provided, with subsequent approval by the local Animal Care Committee.


 Recommended Methods of Euthanasia (by species):
 

FISH: 

    Chemical methods 
    • Tricaine methane sulfonate (MS 222) immersion overdose. Neutralized to pH 7.5 with bicarbonate 
    • Benzocaine immersion overdose. Neutralized to pH 7.5 with bicarbonate 
    Physical methods 
    • Concussion followed by exsanguination, removal of the heart or cervical dislocation
    Anaesthetized fish: 
    • Pithing
    • Decapitation
    • Exsanguination

 

AMPHIBIANS:

    Chemical methods 
    • MS 222 immersion overdose. Neutralized to pH 7.5 with bicarbonate 
    • Benzocaine immersion overdose. Neutralized to pH 7.5 with bicarbonate
    • Sodium pentobarbital overdose (intravenous, IV or intraperitoneal, IP)
    Physical methods 
    • Concussion followed by pithing
    • Decapitation and pithing 
    Anaesthetized amphibians 
    • Pithing

 

REPTILES:

    Chemical methods 
    • Sodium pentobarbital overdose (IV or IP)
    Physical methods 
    • Captive bolt followed by destruction of brain
    Anaesthetized reptiles: 
    • Pithing
    • Decapitation
    Note: For amphibian and reptilian species, inhalational anaesthetics are an unacceptable means of euthanasia due to breath holding capacity, resulting in prolonged induction times. 

 

BIRDS:

    Chemical methods 
    • CO2 (in chicks up to 72 hours old)
    • Volatile inhalational anaesthetic overdose
    • Sodium pentobarbital overdose (IV or IP)
    Physical methods 
    • Concussion followed by exsanguination or decapitation
    • Anaesthetized birds:
    • Decapitation
    • Pithing
    • Potassium chloride
    Note: exsanguination is unacceptable in birds due to rapid blood clotting 

 
 

RODENTS:

    Chemical methods 
    • Sodium pentobarbital overdose (IV or IP)
    • Inhalation anaesthetic overdose
    • CO2 (animals more than 10 days old)
    Physical methods 
    • Microwave irradiation in specially designed units
    Anaesthetized rodents 
    • Cervical dislocation
    • Decapitation
    • Rapid freezing
    • Exsanguination
RABBITS
    Chemical methods 
    • Sodium pentobarbital overdose (IV or IP)
    • Inhalation anaesthetic overdose – prior sedation mandatory 
    Anaesthetized rabbits 
    • Exsanguination
    • Potassium chloride

 
 

CARNIVORES: Dogs, cats, ferrets

    Chemical methods 
    • Sodium pentobarbital overdose (IV only) – prior sedation mandatory 
    • Inhalational anaesthetic overdose – prior sedation mandatory
    Physical methods (field conditions only) 
    • Shooting
    Anaesthetized carnivores 
    • Exsanguination
    • Potassium chloride

 

LARGE MAMMALS (Pigs, sheep, goats, cattle)

    Chemical methods 
    • Sodium pentobarbital overdose (IV only) – prior sedation mandatory 
    • Inhalation anaesthetic overdose (lambs and kids only) – prior sedation mandatory 
    Physical methods (field conditions only) 
    • Captive bolt followed by exsanguination
    • Free bullet humane killers
    • Shooting
    Anaesthetized large mammals 
    • Exsanguination
    • Potassium chloride

 

NON-HUMAN PRIMATES

    Chemical methods 
    • Sodium pentobarbital overdose (IV only) – prior sedation mandatory 

 
 
 
 
 
 

Unacceptable Methods of Euthanasia for All Species:

  • Air embolism
  • Burning (chemical or thermal)
  • Carbon monoxide 
  • Chloral hydrate
  • Chloroform
  • Cyanide
  • Decompression / vacuum
  • Drowning
  • Diethyl ether
  • Exsanguination without anaesthesia
  • Formalin
  • Household products and solvents
  • Hypothermia / hyperthermia
  • Ketamine
  • Magnesium sulfate
  • Methoxyflurane
  • Narcotics
  • Neuromuscular blocking agents
  • Nitrous oxide
  • Rapid freezing without anaesthesia
  • Removal from water (gilled vertebrates)
  • Strangulation
  • Strychnine